Drag
  • Tax Strategy
  • Planning
  • Real Wealth

I’m 58 With $5 Million. Should I Sell My $2.5 Million in Company Stock?

Published

October 27, 2026

Author

Steven Weigandt

Subscribe to our newsletter

You’re 58, you have $5 million, and you’re thinking about retirement. On paper, that sounds like a great position. But there’s one complication: $2.5 million is invested in the stock of the company you work for.

The same company that pays your salary is also responsible for half your wealth. This is where the decision gets uncomfortable. That stock may be a big reason you can retire in the first place. You know the business, you’ve watched it grow, and selling could mean a substantial tax bill.

Why walk away from something that’s worked so well? But if you keep it, how much of your retirement are you asking that one company to deliver?

Let’s walk through a hypothetical couple facing this exact situation. We’ll compare keeping the stock, selling it all, and several strategies that fall somewhere in the middle.

The retirement scenario: $5 million with half in company stock

Let’s put some details around this couple so we can work through a real decision. We’ll call them Mr. and Mrs. Concentrated Stock Position. Here’s what their investment portfolio looks like:

  • Concentrated company stock: $2,500,000
  • His 401(k): $1,500,000
  • Her 401(k): $500,000
  • Investment Account: $500,000

We’re not including their house for this exercise. These assets total $5 million in value. The big question is what to do with that $2.5 million in company stock. For me, this starts with something I talk about frequently: connecting the dots.

An ideal financial plan connects tax planning, retirement planning, investments, and estate planning. These decisions affect one another, and we don’t want fragmented decision-making.

Before deciding what to do with the stock, we need to answer two important questions.

First, are you financially independent?

Can this couple actually retire? We always start with retirement modeling. Let’s assume they retire at 60. If they spend $10,000 per month, they’re in a phenomenal position. Their projected net worth later in life could be substantial.

But what happens if they want to spend $40,000 per month? That’s a different story. At that spending level, they’re highly likely to run out of money. Now let’s run the ultimate stress test.

What happens if their $2.5 million company stock position goes to essentially zero?

Could they still retire and spend $10,000 per month? In this hypothetical scenario, the answer is yes. Even with roughly half their portfolio gone, they can still retire and would likely leave a meaningful amount of money behind. That’s important.

They’re independently wealthy, which gives them a lot more flexibility in how they approach the stock.

Second, is the company stock publicly or privately held?

Public stock gives us options that private stock doesn’t. For this example, we’re focusing on publicly traded stock and the strategies available once the employee retires at 60, when insider trading restrictions may be easier to navigate.

Option 1: Keep all the company stock

The first option is simple: keep it. It’s rare that someone wants to hold onto their entire concentrated stock position, but it happens. Our retirement modeling already showed that this couple doesn’t need the stock to perform well to stay retired. That means they have the freedom to make a decision based on more than just the math.

Maybe they love the company. Maybe they believe in its future. Maybe they simply don’t want to pay the taxes. If it’s a profitable, growing company, keeping the stock isn’t necessarily crazy.

Just ask a longtime retired Apple employee. But eventually, the concentration can become pretty significant.

Option 2: Sell all $2.5 million in company stock

Now let’s look at the other extreme: Sell everything. In this example, the couple has:

  • $2.5 million in company stock
  • $500,000 in cost basis
  • $2 million in capital gains

Selling the entire position could generate approximately $500,000 to $600,000 in taxes under this hypothetical example’s assumptions.

That’s a substantial tax bill. But before you panic about the number, remember there’s peace of mind in knowing it’s done. You’ve diversified, removed the concentrated risk, and can move on. It’s certainly the simplest approach.

Some people worry about missing future upside. But remember, this couple is already financially independent. We’re largely talking about how much wealth they’ll leave to their children rather than whether they’ll have enough money for retirement.

And the roughly $2 million remaining after taxes could be invested in something like the S&P 500. That money could grow to a substantial amount, too. Plus, many individual companies don’t outperform the S&P 500 over time. Still, most people aren’t going to choose either extreme. The answer is usually somewhere in the middle.

Six strategies for managing concentrated company stock

This is where we start building a personalized sell-down plan based on your goals, your company, and your tax situation. There are several strategies worth evaluating. These can get intricate, so I’m going to simplify them to help you understand what’s available.

1. Protective put

A protective put is an options strategy where you pay for downside protection. Essentially, you’re purchasing a floor beneath the stock’s value while keeping the potential upside.

2. Collar

A collar provides downside protection at a lower cost, but you give up some potential upside in exchange. You’re protecting against losses while accepting a limit on future gains.

3. Zero-cost collar

A zero-cost collar provides a floor with no net option premium. How? By giving up more of the stock’s potential upside.

4. Put spread collar

A put spread collar offers less expensive protection, but only across a defined range of stock-price declines.

These first four strategies all use options to manage downside risk. Now let’s look at two approaches that work differently.

5. Prepaid variable forward

A prepaid variable forward allows you to receive a percentage of your stock’s value in cash upfront from a financial institution. In exchange, the arrangement establishes a floor and cap on the stock’s future value.

Let’s say our hypothetical couple wants to spend $10,000 per month in retirement, but they also want to purchase a second home. They may need access to cash now without selling their entire stock position immediately. A prepaid variable forward could be worth evaluating in that situation.

6. Exchange fund

An exchange fund allows an investor to contribute concentrated stock in exchange for an interest in a diversified pool of investments. The transaction can provide tax deferral, but the investment is generally locked up for an extended period.

These funds are appropriate only for certain investors and certain types of stock. Again, there’s a lot more to each of these strategies. The important thing is understanding that selling everything or keeping everything aren’t your only choices.

Five additional tax, real estate, and charitable strategies

Beyond those six approaches, there are five more strategies we may consider depending on your circumstances.

1. Cost segregation study

If a client wants to diversify out of company stock and into real estate, we might explore selling stock, purchasing real estate, and using a cost segregation study.

The idea is to identify depreciation deductions that may help offset taxable income associated with the transaction. This can be particularly interesting for investors who already want to own real estate.

2. Opportunity zones

Opportunity zones are designated areas throughout the United States where qualifying investments may receive favorable tax treatment.

An investor may be able to sell appreciated stock and reinvest eligible gains into a qualifying opportunity zone investment to defer certain taxes. Changes to opportunity zone legislation have created additional planning considerations for 2027. For investors interested in real estate, this is another strategy worth exploring.

3. Deferred sales trusts

Deferred sales trusts are another potential approach. The goal is to diversify an appreciated asset while spreading the recognition of taxable gains over time. These arrangements can be complex and require careful evaluation.

4. Charitable trusts

For charitably minded investors, charitable trusts can be powerful. Depending on the structure, an investor may contribute appreciated stock, diversify the assets, receive income over time, and ultimately leave the remaining assets to charity. I like the concept of redirecting wealth toward charitable causes rather than paying all of it in taxes. If giving is already part of your goals, these strategies deserve consideration.

5. Donor-advised funds

Donor-advised funds are another tool we use frequently in tax planning. You can contribute eligible assets, potentially receive a charitable deduction, and recommend grants to charities over time. These can be especially helpful when we’re managing tax brackets and planning charitable giving. 

There are a lot of possibilities here, and each comes with its own requirements, limitations, and tax considerations.

How do you decide which strategy makes sense?

With all these options, where do you start? I would approach the decision in four steps.

Step 1: Build a financial independence model

First and foremost, understand whether you can retire and what your financial future looks like. We need to evaluate your complete financial picture before making a decision about one investment.

Step 2: Determine how dependent you are on the stock

How much does your retirement depend on this particular company performing well? If your company stock needs to grow at 8% annually for you to remain retired, that’s going to lead to a very different strategy.

Compare that to our hypothetical couple, who can meet their retirement spending needs even if the company stock becomes essentially worthless.

Those are two very different situations.

Step 3: Understand your “why”

This decision can be incredibly emotional. We need to understand your fears, your goals, and what you’re trying to accomplish. Maybe you’re worried about paying taxes. Maybe you’re emotionally attached to the company. Maybe you’re concerned about leaving money to your children.

Those things matter. Understanding your why helps us determine which strategies actually make sense.

Step 4: Model and stress-test your options

Once we understand your financial position and goals, we can evaluate the strategies. We model them, stress-test them, and determine which approach fits your situation. And here’s something important:

This is often a year-by-year decision.

Tax rules change. Your circumstances change. The stock’s performance changes. Outside of selling everything immediately, you don’t necessarily need to commit to one strategy for the next 20 years. You can make thoughtful decisions one year at a time. There’s a great line about how to eat an elephant: one bite at a time. The same idea applies here.

A company stock decision shaped by the retirement plan

The bottom line: Your company stock decision should fit your retirement plan. Having $5 million at age 58 puts you in a strong financial position, but having half of that wealth tied to one company makes this decision worth taking seriously.

The right answer depends on your retirement spending, tax situation, investment goals, estate plan, and how much risk you’re comfortable carrying.

For some people, keeping the stock may make sense. For others, selling it could provide peace of mind. And for many, a personalized strategy somewhere in the middle may be the best fit.

The important thing is making sure all the pieces of your financial plan work together.

If you’re approaching retirement with a concentrated company stock position, let’s talk.

At Perspective Wealth Advisors, we look at your retirement goals, investments, taxes, and estate planning to understand how everything fits together.

Schedule a call with our team. We’d love to talk through it with you.

This article is for educational purposes only and uses a hypothetical example. The strategies discussed involve investment, tax, and legal considerations and may not be appropriate for every investor. Tax outcomes depend on individual circumstances and applicable law. Consult qualified financial, tax, and legal professionals before implementing any strategy.

Once we talk, you’ll see the difference.

95% of people become ongoing clients after consult.

This figure is based on internal firm data for consults conducted between January 2025 and December 2025. Individual decisions to engage our firm vary based on personal circumstances. Past engagement rates are not indicative of future results and should not be construed as a guarantee of client experience.